Before surgery
Second opinion before hip surgery
A hip second opinion is an independent review of your diagnosis and proposed operation by another hip surgeon. It is especially worth considering if you are young and have been offered a total hip replacement, have hip dysplasia or have received conflicting diagnoses. Dr Luis Ramírez Núñez reviews your MRI, CT, X-rays and reports online or in Barcelona.
Dr. Luis Ramírez Núñez · Hip surgeon · COMB licence no. 56226 · Updated: November 2026

Priority for private patients
Priority appointments at our Tuset clinic
On this page · 10 sections
Getting a second opinion before hip surgery means asking another hip surgeon to look at the same images, reports and symptoms and to tell you, independently, whether the diagnosis holds up and whether the operation you have been offered is the right one for you. It is not a sign of distrust towards your doctor. For many people it is simply the step that allows them to go ahead, or to wait, with a clear head. Dr Luis Ramírez Núñez, an orthopaedic surgeon in the Hip Section of Hospital Clínic de Barcelona, reviews hip cases online for patients wherever they live and, when needed, in person in Barcelona.
Why patients ask for a second opinion
Second opinions are common in orthopaedic surgery. In a Dutch study of 2,079 consecutive new patients at an orthopaedic outpatient clinic, 30% had already seen another consultant for the same problem in the previous two years (van Dalen et al., 2001). They had not come because they doubted the competence of their first surgeon. They came because they wanted more information about their condition and its treatment, or because they were dissatisfied with the communication or with the results of the treatment so far.
In hip surgery there is an additional reason. Several hip conditions in young adults can be treated in more than one way, and the options that keep your own joint are not always raised at the first appointment. A second opinion gives you the chance to hear all of them before an irreversible decision.
When a second opinion makes sense before hip surgery
You are under 40 and have been offered a total hip replacement
A total hip replacement is a well-established operation, but your age matters when you think about the long term. In a population study from the United Kingdom covering hip and knee replacements, the lifetime risk of needing revision surgery was about 5% for patients operated on after the age of 70, and it rose in younger patients, up to 35% for men in their early fifties (Bayliss et al., 2017). The authors recommend that these figures form part of shared decision-making with patients. If you are young, it is reasonable to ask whether your hip could be preserved, or whether hip resurfacing is an option in your case. Both alternatives are explained on the page about hip replacement and hip resurfacing in Barcelona.
You have hip dysplasia and nobody has mentioned an osteotomy
In hip dysplasia, the socket of the hip (the acetabulum) does not cover the head of the femur well enough. The operation designed to correct this in adults is the periacetabular osteotomy (PAO), which reorients the socket while keeping your own joint. In the first 63 patients (75 hips) treated with this technique at the centre where it was developed, 60% of the hips were still preserved at a mean follow-up of about 20 years (Steppacher et al., 2008). The same study identified factors linked to a poorer outcome, including older age at surgery, worse function before the operation, a limp, a positive impingement test and more advanced arthritis. In other words, timing matters, and a second look is worthwhile if you have only been told about a replacement.
You have been offered a PAO or a hip arthroscopy and want to confirm the indication
Some patients already have a plan for joint-preserving surgery and want to be sure that it is the right one and to understand what the recovery involves before committing to it. A review can confirm the indication for a periacetabular osteotomy or a hip arthroscopy, or explain why another approach might suit your hip better.
You are active, you have arthritis and resurfacing was never discussed
If you are an active person or play sport and have been diagnosed with hip osteoarthritis, you may want to know whether hip resurfacing is an option for you before a conventional total hip replacement. Resurfacing keeps the head and neck of the femur and is considered for selected younger, active patients.
Two doctors have told you different things
Specialists do not always agree, particularly when a decision rests on plain X-rays alone. At a British Hip Society meeting, hip surgeons shown the same cases reached only fair agreement on the diagnosis of the type of femoroacetabular impingement and of dysplasia from plain radiographs. Among high-volume hip preservation surgeons, agreement improved substantially once CT or MRI was added (Malviya et al., 2016). The authors concluded that agreement on diagnosis and treatment based on plain radiographs is low among general hip surgeons and improves with surgeon volume and experience.
You simply want to be sure
Sometimes the diagnosis is clear and a decision has already been made, but you want to confirm that the proposed operation is the right option for your particular case, or you would like to be treated by a surgeon who inspires confidence and with whom you can talk openly. That is also a good reason to ask.
Questions worth asking yourself
If you are unsure whether you need a second opinion, these questions can help:
- Were you offered a single option, without any alternatives being explained?
- Were you told “replacement” regardless of your age and your diagnosis?
- Has anyone talked to you about preserving your own hip before replacing it?
- Do you understand what the operation involves and what the recovery would look like?
- Have two specialists given you different explanations for the same pain?
If you answered yes to any of them, it may be worth having your case reviewed.
Why the images matter more than the reports
A radiology report is one person’s reading of your images. For a second opinion to be meaningful, the surgeon needs to see and measure the images themselves. Some measurements are more dependable than others: a systematic review of 43 studies found that the lateral centre-edge angle, a standard X-ray measurement of how well the socket covers the femoral head, had the strongest evidence of reliability (acceptable in all 22 studies that tested it), whereas the Tönnis grading of osteoarthritis consistently showed subpar agreement, both between different observers and when the same observer repeated the reading (Carreira & Emmons, 2019). Two people can therefore look at the same hip and grade its arthritis differently, and the degree of arthritis is one of the factors linked to the long-term result of joint-preserving surgery (Steppacher et al., 2008).
This is also why cross-sectional imaging is useful: in the British Hip Society study, adding CT or MRI substantially improved diagnostic agreement among experienced hip preservation surgeons (Malviya et al., 2016).
What to send for a remote review
You do not usually need new tests for a first assessment: your current imaging and reports are normally enough. If something important is missing, you will be told exactly which test would help.
| What to send | Format | Why it helps |
|---|---|---|
| Hip and pelvis X-rays | Image files, plus the report | Standard measurements of coverage and shape, such as the lateral centre-edge angle, are made on X-rays |
| MRI or MR arthrogram | The complete study as image files, plus the report | Adding cross-sectional imaging improved diagnostic agreement among experienced hip preservation surgeons |
| CT scan, with 3D reconstructions if available | The complete study as image files, plus the report | As above |
| Clinic letters and the proposed plan | PDF or clear photos | Shows what has been diagnosed, what has been tried and which operation has been proposed |
| Operative notes, if you have had hip surgery | PDF or clear photos | Shows exactly what was done before |
| A short summary in your own words | A few lines | How long you have had symptoms, what makes them worse, what you have tried and what you want to get back to |
Please do not send your images by WhatsApp message before you have been told how: the team will indicate a secure way to share them.
How the remote review works
- Get in touch. Write by WhatsApp on +34 686 563 707, call the same number or email programacion@jointclinic.es. Tell us where you are writing from, what you have been diagnosed with and which operation you have been offered.
- Share your imaging securely. You will receive instructions on how to send your images and reports.
- Video consultation. Dr Ramírez goes through your history and your images with you in English or Spanish, explains what he sees and sets out the options, including any that may not have been discussed before.
- An agreed next step. Depending on your case, that may mean continuing with your current surgeon with more confidence, completing a specific test, or planning treatment in Barcelona. If surgery is considered, an in-person visit in Barcelona is arranged and any missing tests are coordinated before you travel.
Fees and timings are confirmed when you get in touch.
What you get from a second opinion
- An explanation of your diagnosis in plain language, based on your own images.
- A view on whether the proposed operation fits your situation: your age, the state of your joint and the activities you want to return to.
- The alternatives, including joint-preserving surgery, hip resurfacing or non-surgical treatment where they are reasonable options.
- Which further tests, if any, would change the decision.
- A clear next step, whichever surgeon you decide to be treated by.
Whether the online review also includes a written summary, and in what format, is confirmed when you book.
What a remote review can and cannot do
Reviewing a case at a distance has clear advantages and some limits. In a qualitative study of 40 patients who obtained a second opinion through a document-based online platform, mostly for orthopaedic problems, patients valued access to distant specialists, consulting from home without waiting and the timeliness of the answer. The challenges were that it could feel impersonal, that technical problems could arise, that it was difficult to describe symptoms in writing and that there was little room for spontaneous questions (Bruch et al., 2025). The authors identified a clear medical question and a well-organised process as keys to success. That is why the review starts with a live video consultation rather than a written exchange only, and why an in-person visit in Barcelona is arranged before any operation is planned.
Who reviews your case
Your case is reviewed personally by Dr Luis Ramírez Núñez, an orthopaedic surgeon who has worked in the Hip Section of Hospital Clínic de Barcelona since 2021. He completed his specialist training in Orthopaedic Surgery and Traumatology in Spain through the MIR residency system (Tarragona–Tortosa, 2012-2017), carried out an observership in the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago in 2016, and worked in hip preservation at the Institut Universitari Quirón Dexeus in Barcelona from 2017 to 2021, in the team of Dr Manel Ribas. With that team he published the mid-term results of 131 periacetabular osteotomies performed through a mini-invasive approach (Ramírez-Núñez et al., 2020).
He is the medical director of Joint Clinic, a joint preservation unit at Hospital El Pilar – Quirónsalud, and founder of the Institut Mèdic Especialitzat La Ràpita. He is registered with the Barcelona College of Physicians (COMB, no. 56226) and is a member of the Spanish Hip Society (SECCA), the Spanish Society of Orthopaedic Surgery and Traumatology (SECOT) and the Catalan Society of Orthopaedic Surgery and Traumatology (SCCOT). He sees patients in English and Spanish; if you are part of the Venezuelan community abroad, see the page for Venezuelan patients.
Next step
To ask for a second opinion, write by WhatsApp or call +34 686 563 707, or email programacion@jointclinic.es. You will find all contact options, and information for patients travelling from abroad, on the international patients page. If your hip pain has not yet been diagnosed, the guide on hip pain is a good place to start.
Frequently asked questions
Does a second opinion mean leaving my current surgeon?
No. A second opinion is an independent review, not a transfer of care. Many patients go back to their original surgeon with a clearer understanding of the plan, and others choose to continue their treatment in Barcelona. The decision stays with you, and you can share the conclusions of the review with the doctor who is treating you now.
Do I need to repeat my scans for a hip second opinion?
Usually not. Your current X-rays, MRI or CT scans, with their reports, are normally enough for a first assessment. Send the image files themselves, not only the written reports, so that the images can be reviewed and measured directly. If something important is missing, you will be told exactly which test would help before any decision is made.
Is a second opinion worth it if I already have a date for surgery?
Yes, particularly if you still have doubts. For planned hip operations there is usually time to confirm the indication before going ahead. Get in touch as early as you can, mention your date and send your complete imaging so that the review is ready in time. In emergencies, such as a hip fracture, follow the advice of the team treating you.
Is a hip second opinion only for hip replacement?
No. It is also useful for hip dysplasia, femoroacetabular impingement, labral tears and any diagnosis where you want to confirm the treatment plan, including a proposed periacetabular osteotomy or hip arthroscopy. In younger and active patients, the review also considers whether joint-preserving surgery or hip resurfacing could be alternatives to a total hip replacement.
Can the whole second opinion be done online?
The first assessment can be done entirely online: you share your imaging and reports, and Dr Ramírez goes through them with you in a video consultation in English or Spanish. If surgery is then considered, an in-person visit in Barcelona is arranged so that you can be examined, and any missing tests are coordinated before you travel.
What should I send for a remote hip review?
Send your hip and pelvis X-rays, any MRI or CT scans as image files, all radiology reports, clinic letters describing the proposed operation and, if you have had hip surgery before, the operative notes. Add a short summary of your symptoms, what you have tried and your goals. Wait for instructions before sending images, so that they are shared securely.
In which languages can I have the consultation?
Dr Luis Ramírez Núñez sees patients in English and Spanish, both online and in person in Barcelona. You can contact the team by WhatsApp or phone on +34 686 563 707, or by email at programacion@jointclinic.es, in either language, and your reports can be in English or Spanish.
References
- van Dalen I, Groothoff J, Stewart R, Spreeuwenberg P, Groenewegen P, van Horn J. Motives for seeking a second opinion in orthopaedic surgery. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2001;6(4):195-201.
- Malviya A, Raza A, Witt JD. Reliability in the diagnosis of femoroacetabular impingement and dysplasia among hip surgeons: role of surgeon volume and experience. Hip Int. 2016;26(3):284-9.
- Carreira DS, Emmons BR. The reliability of commonly used radiographic parameters in the evaluation of the pre-arthritic hip: a systematic review. JBJS Rev. 2019;7(2):e3.
- Bayliss LE, Culliford D, Monk AP, et al. The effect of patient age at intervention on risk of implant revision after total replacement of the hip or knee: a population-based cohort study. Lancet. 2017;389(10077):1424-1430.
- Steppacher SD, Tannast M, Ganz R, Siebenrock KA. Mean 20-year followup of Bernese periacetabular osteotomy. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2008;466(7):1633-1644.
- Bruch D, May S, Könsgen N, et al. Benefits and challenges of asynchronous telemedicine in obtaining a second opinion: a qualitative interview study. BMJ Open. 2025;15(7):e100287.
- Ramírez-Núñez L, Payo-Ollero J, Comas M, et al. Periacetabular osteotomy for hip dysplasia treatment through a mini-invasive technique. Our results at mid-term in 131 cases. Rev Esp Cir Ortop Traumatol (Engl Ed). 2020;64(3):151-159.
This information is educational and does not replace an individual medical assessment.
